|Tuesday, July 30, 2013|
|More than Political Will|
Tallinn has been a Top 7 Intelligent Community five times. From an ICF perspective it is clearly an ICT superstar. It is a community that has had strong local and national leadership and has taken advantage of the technology that is available to it and makes no bones about using it. Some would even say that it has achieved this success through political will.
I have had the opportunity to visit Tallinn several times. Tallinn is without a doubt a high-velocity intelligent community that has taken exciting, but calculated risks to create a city that its citizens can be very proud of. As my hosts explained, the citizens of Tallinn benefit from the enlightenment of their government leaders. Tallinn rose out from under the iron curtain in 1991 and in many cases had to learn how to become entrepreneurial, take risks and learn to become an intelligent community. As a city and region, it has had a long history of conquests with many different governments coming into power and building and running most aspects of it. Today it’s still very much that way. As my hosts would say, “in our culture, government provides for more than 80% of the way things are done and then, the rest of our activities are provided by the private sector.”
Although Tallinn has much government support and influence in nearly everything that gets done in the community, the city has a wonderful feel and sense about itself. It is not oppressed and uninviting. In fact, there is much to do, from spectacular medieval tourism, to international-level entertainment and interesting and highly rated restaurants. The exceptional heritage of the medieval community is UNESCO protected.
In a meeting with Tallinn’s Mayor, Edgar Savisaar and his City Secretary, Toomas Sepp, they explained that through political will, free mobility for its citizens on all buses, trams and shuttles was launched in January 2013 (yes, that is right, free transit for every Tallinn citizen!). This program was designed to encourage an increase in environmentally-friendly transit, lower car dependency and to increase registration of citizens, thereby helping to increase the local tax-rolls. This action has already paid for itself by an increase of tens of thousands new citizens registered for the free transit passes. The city also has an extensive e-platform where many civic and other e-services are provided. Free wireless access seems to be everywhere in the city.
The country saw a major boom in the mid-2000’s when significant Scandinavian investment came to Estonia. But the financial crisis that followed in 2008 was very difficult for Tallinn with thousands of companies going bankrupt and thousands of low-skilled workers becoming unemployed. Today, despite efforts to keep their talent, especially skilled workers, doctors and those in service industries, many have moved to Scandinavia and elsewhere to seek employment. My hosts lament that in Finland these workers are attracted by salaries and benefits three times that which Estonia offers. They recognize that more needs to be done and in a hurry to stem the tide of skilled workers leaving the country.
During a private meeting with the Estonian President, Toomas Hendrik Ilves, we discussed Estonia’s excellence in cyber security and the global respect that counties have for Estonia’s security experience. He also told me that while the Estonian government support will continue in its expertise in cyber security, they must now also focus on education, developing skilled workers, and more importantly finding ways to retain their talent as well as promote and encourage entrepreneurialism, especially research-based entrepreneurialism.
I had visited several years before and during my first visit was honoured to have dinner with one of the founders of Skype. We discussed his next venture having sold Skype to Microsoft. Everyone I met in Tallinn seemed to be, or wanted to be, a serial entrepreneur. The Skype story was what everyone in Estonia talked about and wanted to emulate – to be the next Skype success story. This can be possible if the same political will is directed to creating an environment, an ecosystem that will nurture creativity, innovational and entrepreneurialism. It seems that this is on its way. For instance, the city’s free wireless services and extensive high-speed broadband throughout the municipality is now being augmented by the Broadband Alliance’s “EstWin” initiative that will extend broadband throughout Estonia; a significant contribution to digital inclusion for all Estonians. Tallinn and its educational and business partners have launched multiple incubators targeting medical and biotech, mechatronics, ICT and creative services, including Europe’s first gaming accelerator. In addition, its Ülemiste City industrial estate has expanded to house 250 companies, making it the Baltic’s biggest knowledge-based development. Incubators are growing to support innovation and creative industries; there is a sense that supporting start-ups will attract and retain local and foreign talent to nurture much needed diversity across scientific, industrial and commercial sectors. As advocates, the sense of the Intelligent Community movement penetrates much of the government and institutional sectors.
Tallinn’s leaders seem keen to do the right thing and are looking at innovative ways to evolve and sustain their community as an Intelligent Community. And they are embarking on a new attitude toward creating an environment supportive of entrepreneurialism to see it through. While Enterprise Estonia is funded primarily by government funds, it supports entrepreneurs enthusiastically. The community is actively looking to help support the next Skype to evolve out of Tallinn’s many start-ups. For instance “Garage48”, a small band of highly entrepreneurial and networked folks in Tallinn has evolved to encourage entrepreneurialism through networking and sharing of ideas. However, they lack the funds to assist companies directly. While fledgling, they have a great sense of spirit and enthusiasm and attract many new start-ups to their new facilities for networking events. Their motto “Screw it; Let’s do it” speaks for itself.
In seeking new ways to stop the brain drain and reverse the tide toward achieving a new brain gain, Tallinn and Estonia’s leadership will need to develop policies, programs and strong initiatives to encourage retention of their talent. This is not an Estonian problem alone. Globally, companies, universities and cities are seeking to attract and retain the best and brightest of their talent. Competition is fierce. New ideas are emerging to evolve entrepreneurial ecosystems to encourage growth. For instance, understanding and benefitting from talent mobility may become the next big idea. It is a challenge that Tallinn and Estonia are facing today; but with political will, they will no doubt find a route on their next journey.
|Tuesday, July 23, 2013|
|Detroit Takes a Shot|
Before my tenth birthday I had nailed a perfect jump shot over the arms of the mayor of Detroit.
The current Mayor of Detroit, USA, Dave Bing, has been in the news often these days. It is not the way he wanted to re-enter the spotlight. He is experiencing something he never imagined in his city. Detroit, as people worldwide know, has become the epicenter of a crisis and the focus of a debate that was long ago settled by those of us in the Intelligent Community movement. Its declaration of bankruptcy, while painful to witness, is ultimately a non-event to most observers. It is the last chapter of a post-Industrial Age saga whose end was written long ago. Stories like the one in Michigan, as we know, have had multiple endings. Not all are as sad as this giant’s tale, where the number of industrial jobs has fallen from 300,000 in 1962 to a mere 27,000 last week, and it takes nearly an hour for a first responder to arrive after a 911 call. Many have an opposite end. There are stories of rebirth. Chattanooga comes first to mind. Eindhoven in the Netherlands and Sunderland, England also have a fine story to tell the world. Their stories are told by ICF and are studied by others.
The modern tales of urban rise and fall, or in Detroit’s case of falling further, have been written by hundreds of authors around the world. These authors are people who understand what is at the end of the assembly line for the next generation of workers who are scandalously undereducated, poorly-served by a corrupt and visionless political class and who hold onto illusions and balance sheets woven without the benefit of reality. As Nobel recipient Paul Krugman rather cold-heartedly wrote yesterday, “Decline happens.” It is true. But it is not inevitable. Nor is it a crime. It is a shame. Cities like Detroit have one common characteristic. None seem to factor in to their calculation that the only truth of life worth remembering is that everything is impermanent except change itself. Most of us learn that lesson way too late, having been led to believe that it just ain’t so. It is. Only the enlightened embrace it as core to their lives and factor it in to the management of their cities and towns.
However my Dave Bing story is of another kind. Of another Summer day. It is a childhood memory of a happier era in both of our lives. My story is a tale of what we used to call “endless summer.” When, as George Gershwin wrote, “the livin’ was easy.” It takes place in another part of the world which was touched, as was Detroit, by a similar illusion of permanence. On one summer afternoon, however, illusions were fine and hung in the moist air of an Upstate New York village. For a nine-year old kid it felt just fine.
That Summer the current mayor of Detroit was not a beleaguered, usurped politician. He was, like the glittering city of Detroit, the essence of grace, power and success. Mr. Bing is even today known for his long, distinguished career as a professional basketball player. The mayor had game. The mayor could thump hoops. Big time. He was a point guard with a sweet jump shot. So sweet that he was elected to the National Basketball Association’s all-star team many times. He is in the league’s Hall of Fame today and after his career in sports went on to become a success at business, a good father and eventually a politician. Detroit was his home.
Lyons, New York was mine. While Mayor Bing was rising to great heights as a premier athlete, I was an elementary school point guard with not much game. But like him I had a pretty good jump shot, great ambition and a kid’s illusions. Mr. Bing was my idol. He was someone I admired from afar. His ability to spring ramrod straight into the air, release a basketball from his long fingers with perfect rotation and land softly as the ball swished through a basket, were the images in my head every time I practiced my jumpshot – which I did for hours and hours each day.
One afternoon, in a convergence only the Great Spirit could direct, he came to my little hometown in the Finger Lakes region to play a pickup game of basketball! At the time he was a college player, a star at nearby Syracuse University. He was in my village thanks to his university roommate, who also was a pretty good basketball player and lived in Lyons. This would be college Hall of Fame basketball coach Jim Boeheim. Jimmy is the second-most successful coach in American college basketball history, and has two Olympic gold medals as the USA Men’s assistant coach to his credit. There is a sign acknowledging that Lyons is his hometown. You can see it, in bright orange, as you drive from Route 14 south into the village, where you also pass the cemetery where his father and mine are buried. They were close friends. It was a close community.
Word went out that Bing was playing in town at an outdoor basketball court that a local town justice had built for his son. Viral marketing in those days resulted in a lot of kids rushing up Foster Street in their Converse sneakers to see The Man and his jump shot. It was a phenomenal thing to see! What made it more phenomenal was that he challenged guys to play him one-on-one. I am not sure how it ultimately went down, but somehow the little runt who lived on Maple Street, who was always talking (me), got a chance to face him. I am here to testify that the giant was gentle.
I started to “trash talk” him I am sure. Given the fact that I was a popular little guy on the street and there to humor the big guys, it was my role. Bing missed his shot, on purpose. It was my turn. I took the ball and I stared him down, as he is staring down Detroit’s woes. My heart beat fast. As I had seen him do on TV, I faked right, moved left and after a single bounce arched the ball toward the rim. All I remember is his outstretched hand, obviously being held back. It still looked like a 40-foot tree. If he had wanted, he could have slapped my shot three counties east. But of course he did not. I have no idea if the rest of this is true, because I had a sort of blackout. But I was told that the ball swished through the hoop and that Dave Bing lost the only game of the afternoon against the future co-captain of the Lyons High School basketball team, and co-founder of ICF.
Some stories are made to teach. This is one of them. Bing was a role model who lived up to the essence of one that day. My confidence was lifted for life. Thanks, Dave (and Jimmy).
Now it is time for us to give him a shot at a bigger, more important goal. Those of us leading ICF and the movement, especially the mayors of our Intelligent Communities, can reach out our hands to Mayor Dave and to Detroit and show him how he can rewrite his story.
|Monday, July 15, 2013|
|How Successful Cities Create a Culture of Progress|
Last week, ICF opened its 2013-2014 Awards cycle (next deadline September 23!) and introduced our theme for the year: Community as Canvas. It looks at the role of culture in the progress of a city or region.
Culture? Why are we asking about that instead of megabits per second or incubators and business accelerators? Why did we write a white paper, Community as Canvas, about three specific aspects of culture in Intelligent Communities? That’s what a blogger for Cisco asked me last week during an interview.
Here’s why. ICF studies how cities and regions use information and communications technology to create prosperity, so people naturally think we’re all about technology. But actually, we have never been. ICF is about that unique place where technology intersects with human beings in a local context. And where humans are, there is culture. We are as dependent on culture as we are on the air we breathe.
If you follow the news these days, you cannot help coming across stories of cultural conflict. Egypt is being torn apart by a conflict between young people importing ideals of non-sectarian democracy and those who see any modern, non-Islamic culture as unacceptable. But the culture wars are cropping up everywhere, from the street protests of Brazil to the strains affecting the European Union. In my country’s politics, the cultures of the conservative and liberal wings have so little in common that they have completely different interpretations of the words they are fighting over.
Culture is also the foundation for all progress. No less an innovator than Sir Isaac Newton wrote that, if he had seen a bit further into the universe than the rest of us, it was “by standing on the shoulders of giants.” With those words he paid tribute to the learning he had gained from others and a lifetime of support and encouragement for his own development – to the culture that made possible his achievements.
When we seek to chart a new course, as Intelligent Communities do, culture matters most of all. The culture of the community forms the launch pad for every program and project. It provides a wide range of intangible assets that Intelligent Community champions put to use. It helps determine how readily new ideas are accepted. It can supply the words that persuasively explain a vision of the future and build support for it, and the narrative that helps people understand where they belong in a changing world.
Or it can cause everything those champions attempt to blow up in their faces.
Underneath the digital ripples of our connected age flows the deep river of human culture, unchanged in its essential operation for millennia. Humanity will continue to respond to change as it has always responded, will embrace what seems good and fear what it does not yet understand. Yet that same culture is at the heart of what ICF calls advocacy: the process of education and persuasion by which a city’s people become its most potent drivers of progress.
That’s why Intelligent Community leaders think about the cultural drivers of the community, and find ways to turn them in the direction of progress. Unless they do, all the megabits and incubators in the world will profit them not at all.
|Monday, July 8, 2013|
|The Skills Gap in Manufacturing: An Unwelcome Blast From the Past|
There is a place in the Netherlands, that land of relaxed efficiency, where high-tech rules. Actually there is more than one. But the one I know best is the Eindhoven Region, which was our 2011 Intelligent Community of the Year. Here, they pull off the parlor trick of being a high-cost country and yet leading in manufacturing through leading-edge technology in the hands of a highly skilled workforce.
So it was with great surprise that I learned over dinner with my friend Joep Brouwers, vice director of Brainport Development, that Eindhoven is facing a skills shortage. More specifically, they already have skilled manufacturing jobs going begging, and they expect the situation to worsen. The problem is that talented young people don’t want to work in something as physically demanding, dirty, and economically uncertain as manufacturing.
The Netherlands is not alone. In a 2009 survey by Area Development magazine, 70 percent of American respondents viewed manufacturing as a top priority for the nation’s economy, but only 17 percent considered it a top career choice – despite average manufacturing wages that are $10,000 higher than those of non-manufacturing jobs. Even in China, the world’s factory floor, the lure of manufacturing isn’t what it used to be. The Global Times reported on a Chongqing job fair in early January. An aluminum processing plant offering good starting salaries, free food and accommodations received only 20 applications from high-school graduates, while a real estate company offering a lower salary was deluged with hundreds of job-seekers.
But wait a minute. Arduous and physically demanding? Not on today’s automated assembly lines. Dirty? Most modern factories, even the ones without clean rooms, are probably tidier than my living room. Uncertain and prone to boom and bust? Sure – just like real estate, finance, media and entertainment and a hundred other industries.
How did manufacturing get such a bad reputation? In a word: culture. In this case, culture means the store of shared experience with de-industrialization in the rich world that began in the 1970s.
For more than a generation, the decline of manufacturing was the rich world’s tale of woe. Developing nations moved up the ladder from manufacturing cheap goods cheaply to making extremely sophisticated and high-quality goods cheaply. The explosive growth of world trade brought that competition right to the shores of industrialized nations, and they found to their frustration and shame that they could not compete. Manufacturing declined as jobs moved offshore in a long terrible wave that seemed to have no end and that brought many formerly prosperous places to their knees.
As I wrote recently, those years may finally be coming to a close. Places like Eindhoven point the way to a future in which high-cost countries can compete in manufacturing as long as they make things that exploit their competitive advantage. But the trauma has left its mark. Trauma always does.
The people who raised today’s youth lived through what looked like the death-spiral of manufacturing. They want something better for their children than they experienced themselves. As communities work to match local employment demand with local talents, they need to overcome the anti-manufacturing bias of the new generation. Left unchallenged, legacy has a bad habit of turning into destiny.
|Monday, July 1, 2013|
“Innovation does not automatically create jobs- the innovations must be adopted and used.” Vinton Cerf
“The key issue in a global innovation economy is jobs – good meaningful jobs and generating the talent to be able to meet the requirements of the global skills gap.” Warren Buffet
ICF’s most recent Summit in New York (June 5-7, 2013) focused on innovation and its impact on creating (or destroying) jobs.
Years ago when I was a post graduate student at the University of Manchester, I visited the birthplace of the industrial revolution at Iron Bridge in Shropshire. At that time, the Information Technology and Internet Revolution had not yet begun. But the jobs that were going on around me in Britain at that time - many representing solid manufacturing jobs that no longer exist today - became the casualties of the new industrial revolution: a dynamic brew of the broadband economy mixing connectivity and globalization policies and practices. With high speed broadband, skilled workers and innovation, the inevitable occurred, the destruction of jobs as we know it. Today in addition to the loss of blue collar jobs, there is even the threat of vanishing white collar jobs; not just because the standard tech job uniform is blue jeans and t-Shirts, but the world is changing faster than some care to imagine and even those that have.
Just as the ludites were unable to stop the industrial revolution and stop the shift of jobs, we won’t be able to build a wall around the new innovation revolution, especially as the world of quantum computing and nanotech commercialization unfolds. My answer to this is the same as Tallinn’s impressive start-up group called GARAGE 48 says it best: “Get on with it” or as their poster says: “screw it, let’s do it”…
Adopted and fully implemented innovation destroys jobs and creates new ones. Even if some manufacturing jobs are returning to North America, they won’t be there for those employees that lost their jobs a few years back. Let’s face it – it’s not a human resources issue. It’s a skills and talent issue. 90% of city officials noted in a recent survey by the National League of Cities (NLC) that workforce alignment has not improved over the past year and prospects for improvement looks grim. These city officials report that workforce skills are not keeping pace with employer demand and 53 % say that current local workforce skills are posing a problem for the economic health of their communities. The world’s present labor market systems can’t seem to handle the accelerating rate of innovation.
The key word here is accelerating.
Jobs are evolving faster than educational and employment systems can adapt, resulting in rising unemployment even as employers experience of appropriately skilled workers. This is a waste of human potential.
The old ways of matching people with jobs is broken. What are our communities around the world doing to deal with this global issue? I believe that intelligent communities
have a much better handle on how to resolve this dilemma and have built an environment – an entire ecosystem- that thrives on innovation and empowers everyone to create new value. They put a high value on education and work closely with educational institutions to target and deliver relevant education to meet the demands of jobs for the future, today. These intelligent communities are able to bridge the chasm among innovation, employment and education policies. They accept change, accept failure and are capable and willing to learn new tricks.
These are communities that have already figured out how to commercialize innovation and are now tackling the question of innovation for jobs.
During the annual ICF Summit
, we met the Top 7 Intelligent Communities of 2013: Columbus, Oulu, Stratford, Tallinn, Taoyuan, Toronto and Taichung. These Intelligent Communities represent an elite breed of community; ones that are willing to share, have an ecosystem of innovation and are poised to succeed:
In Columbus, Ohio
, collaboration among city government, academic institutions, businesses and nonprofits, resulted in adding 15,000 new jobs in the last decade, reversing the “brain drain” typical of many similar communities along the Great Lakes.
has created 18,000 new high-tech jobs since 2007, thanks to a decades-old culture of public-private collaboration and its many high-quality educational institutions, including the University of Oulu. They offer a “youth guarantee” and other strategies to help give direction to its under-employed youth, attempting to match new skill sets to new jobs. They are even training 8 year olds to become entrepreneurs and encouraging former Nokia executives to help match skillsets to new job opportunities in the community they love and want to stay in to raise their families.
leveraged ICT to transform its economy. The city-owned utility has built out an extensive open access fiber network with a WiFi overlay and signed agreements with commercial carriers to deliver triple-play and mobile services, enabling, for example, its Stratford Festival to significantly expand its online marketing, to play a key role in the city’s tourism strategy, to help turn Stratford into a test bed for technology pilots and to attract the University of Waterloo to open its Stratford Campus focused on digital media.
’s 23 universities and technical schools generate a knowledge workforce focused on expanding ICT and digital content skills. Tallinn and its educational and business partners have launched multiple incubators targeting creative services, medical and biotech, mechatronics and ICT, including Europe’s first gaming accelerator while its Ülemiste City industrial estate has expanded to house 250 companies, making it the Baltic’s biggest knowledge-based development.
, Taiwan is home to 15 colleges and universities, graduating 25,000 students every year, making it the county with the youngest population in Taiwan along with the challenge to ensure its residents have the skills employers need. To offset this challenge, the County manages a massive effort connecting job seekers with job opportunities, from employment offices to recruitment events, to fill thousands of job opportunities opening yearly in the international airport area serving Taipei and its industrial region with more than 24 industrial parks, 44,000 companies and 10,000 factories.
is Canada’s largest city and often is referred to as one of the world’s more successful places, but it is also challenged to maintain that edge. With over 52% of its current population having been born outside of Canada, Toronto is experiencing an immigration-driven population surge that is straining its hard and soft infrastructure systems. Governments are addressing these challenges with a development strategy stressing ICT, environmental sustainability and innovation. One of the key strategies being implemented is along Toronto’s waterfront where North America’s largest urban renewal project is transforming a vast area along Lake Ontario into a new knowledge-based economic center with 40,000 residential units, one million sq. meters of commercial space, hundreds of hectares of parks as well as a new center for universities and knowledge-based industries, served by a 1 Gbps fiber-to-the-premise network.
and its 17 universities and colleges created a truly lifelong learning system ranging from basic digital education and vocational training to advanced study and continuous skills improvement. It is also aggressively pursuing industrial clustering through development of the Central Taiwan Technology Corridor, which combines science parks, precision manufacturing parks and software parks to give physical shape to its global ambitions. Taichung is also benefitting from an emerging animation and film industry due to the commercial success of Ang Lee’s film Life of Pi, which was primarily filmed in its city. Taichung was selected as the 2013 Intelligent Community of the Year on June 7, 2013 at Steiner Studios in Brooklyn, New York.
Items 91-95 of 294